Bill Fleming Medal
Introduced in 1954 as the Argus Medal 2 for the Victorian newspaper of the time, the Bill Fleming Medal is the longest running individual honour awarded by Football Victoria. Voted by a selection of journalists each and every year, the Bill Fleming Medal has been won by some of the games all-time greats. From post-war legends in Pepe Cubero, Angus Drennan and Vic Janzcyk, to revered Socceroos in Jimmy Rooney, Billy Vojtek and Jim Tansey. Double winners include Fred Falzon, Tommy Cumming and Luke Sherbon, but only one player has claimed the Medal on three occasions, Frank Micic, whose career spanned almost two decades and who earned more representative caps for Victoria than any other player.
| Season | Player | Club |
| 1954 | Maurice Payne | South Yarra |
| 1955 | Mario Busidoni | Juventus |
| 1956 | Pepe Cubero 1 | J.U.S.T. |
| 1956 | Bob Wemyss 1 | Polonia |
| 1957 | John Macleod | Box Hill |
| 1958 | Wim Westerveld | Wilhelmina |
| 1959 | Angus Drennan | Box Hill |
| 1960 | Vic Janczyk | Polonia |
| 1961 | Fred Falzon | George Cross |
| 1962 | Fred Falzon | George Cross |
| 1963 | John Sanchez | Prahran Slavia |
| 1964 | Frank Micic | J.U.S.T. |
| 1965 | George Scott | Juventus |
| 1966 | Peter Aldis | Ringwood Wilhelmina |
| 1967 | Frank Micic | Footscray J.U.S.T. |
| 1968 | Jimmy Rooney | Essendon Lions |
| 1969 | John O'Neill | Hakoah |
| 1970 | David Pygall | Ringwood Wilhelmina |
| 1971 | Jim Pyrgolios | South Melbourne Hellas |
| 1972 | John Gardiner | George Cross |
| 1973 | Frank Micic | Footscray J.U.S.T. |
| 1974 | Jimmy Armstrong | South Melbourne Hellas |
| 1975 | Billy Vojtek | Juventus |
| 1976 | Jim Tansey | Prahran Slavia |
| 1977 | Mick Watkins | Juventus |
| 1978 | Tommy Cumming | Essendon Croatia |
| 1979 | Tommy Cumming | Essendon Croatia |
| 1980 | Jimmy Dunne | Green Gully |
| 1981 | Charlie Egan | Frankston City |
| 1982 | Peter Lewis | Green Gully |
| 1983 | Paul Lewis | Green Gully |
| 1984 | Steve Smith | Box Hill |
| 1985 | Jimmy MacLean | Morwell Falcons |
| 1986 | Alex Dick | Frankston Pines |
| 1987 | Paul Harris | Northcote City |
| 1988 | Ivan Duzel | St Albans |
| 1989 | Velimir Kupresak | St Albans |
| 1990 | Andy Humble | Croydon City |
| 1991 | Fabio Incantalupo | Bulleen |
| 1992 | Fausto De Amicis | Brunswick Juventus |
| 1993 | David Cervinski | North Geelong |
| 1994 | Adrian Pender | Preston Lions |
| 1995 | George Svigos | Port Melbourne Sharks |
| 1996 | Ike Alagiozidis | Bentleigh Greens |
| 1997 | George Jolevski | Altona Magic |
| 1998 | Nick Cuculevski | Thomastown Zebras |
| 1999 | Zlatko Mihajlovic | Springvale White Eagles |
| 2000 | Danny Gnjidic | Bulleen Zebras |
| 2001 | Jim Kourtis | Heidelberg United |
| 2002 | Henry Fa'arodo | Fawkner Blues |
| 2003 | Tony Schipano | Fawkner Blues |
| 2004 | Michael Curcija | Essendon Royals |
| 2005 | Rody Vargas | Green Gully Cavaliers |
| 2006 | Anthony Magnacca | Preston Lions |
| 2007 | Tony Sterjovski | Preston Lions |
| 2008 | Pablo Cardozo | Richmond |
| 2009 | Osagie Ederaro | Heidelberg United |
| 2010 | Kevin Townson | Melbourne Knights |
| 2011 | Richie Cardozo | Hume City |
| 2012 | Luke Sherbon | Dandenong Thunder |
| 2013 | Luke Sherbon | Bentleigh Greens |
| 2014 | Wayne Wallace 1 | Bentleigh Greens |
| 2014 | Nate Foster 1 | Oakleigh Cannons |
| 2015 | Amy Jackson | Boroondara Eagles |
| 2016 | Dusan Bosnjak | Oakleigh Cannons |
| 2017 | Davey van't Schip | Pascoe Vale |
| 2018 | Brandon Barnes | Dandenong Thunder |
| 2019 | Tasuku Sekiya | Avondale |
| 2020 | Not awarded | |
| 2021 | Not awarded | |
| 2022 | Joe Guest | Oakleigh Cannons |
| 2023 | Jonas Markovski | Altona Magic |
Notes:
- Dual winners.
- Known as the Argus Medal between 1954 and 1970.
